Should you rent or buy? Compare your estimated net worth after a number of years, including CMHC mortgage default insurance, the minimum down payment, ownership costs, rent increases and the return you could earn by investing instead.
How this rent vs buy calculator compares the two options
Buying a home and renting are both ways to pay for housing, and neither is automatically better. This calculator follows two households month by month over the same period. The buyer pays the mortgage, property tax, maintenance, condo fees and home insurance, and builds equity as the home appreciates. The renter pays rent and tenant insurance, and invests the down payment and closing costs instead. Each month, whichever option costs less invests the difference at the return you choose. At the end, the buyer's net worth is the home value minus selling costs and the remaining mortgage, plus any investments; the renter's net worth is the investment portfolio.
Down payment and CMHC insurance rules
The calculator applies the federal minimum down payment: 5% on the first $500,000, 10% on the portion from $500,000 to $1.5 million, and 20% for homes of $1.5 million or more. With less than 20% down, the mortgage must have mortgage default insurance, and the premium is added to the loan. CMHC premiums on the total loan are:
| Down payment | Loan-to-value | Premium |
|---|---|---|
| 5% to 9.99% | 90.01% to 95% | 4.00% |
| 10% to 14.99% | 85.01% to 90% | 3.10% |
| 15% to 19.99% | 80.01% to 85% | 2.80% |
| 20% or more | 80% or less | Not required |
A 30-year amortization on an insured mortgage, available to first-time buyers and buyers of new builds, adds 0.20% to the premium. In Ontario, Quebec and Saskatchewan, provincial sales tax on the premium is paid at closing and is not included here. Sources: Financial Consumer Agency of Canada: down payment rules and CMHC: mortgage loan insurance cost.
The formulas
The mortgage payment uses Canadian semi-annual compounding: monthly rate i = (1 + r/2)1/6 − 1 and payment L × i ÷ (1 − (1 + i)−N), where L is the loan including the insurance premium. Home value grows each month at the monthly equivalent of the annual appreciation rate, rent rises once a year, and investments compound monthly. Property tax and maintenance are a percentage of the current home value.
Worked example
A $600,000 home with 10% down ($60,000) at 4.29% over 25 years: CMHC insurance is 3.10% of $540,000, or $16,740, for a total mortgage of $556,740 and a monthly payment of about $3,016.74. With 0.8% property tax, 1% maintenance, $100 home insurance, 3% appreciation, 1.5% closing costs and 5% selling costs, compared with $2,400 rent rising 3% a year and a 5% investment return, after 10 years the buyer's net worth is about $365,000 and the renter's is about $331,000. Change the period to 5 years, or lower appreciation, and the result can flip in favour of renting.
Tips for a fair comparison
- Use realistic appreciation. Home prices can fall as well as rise; test a lower or negative rate.
- Do not forget maintenance. 1% to 2% of the home value per year is a common rule of thumb for older homes.
- The renter must actually invest. Renting only wins if the savings are invested consistently.
- Time matters. Buying and selling costs make short stays expensive; the longer you stay, the more buying tends to pay off.
See also our mortgage calculator for payments and the compound interest calculator for investment growth.
Disclaimer: this calculator provides estimates for general information only and is not financial advice. Results depend on the figures you enter. Your lender, card issuer or a qualified adviser will confirm your actual numbers.
FAQ
Is it better to rent or buy in Canada?
It depends on prices, rents, interest rates, how long you plan to stay and whether you invest the money you save by renting. Over short periods renting often comes out ahead because of buying and selling costs; over longer periods buying often wins if prices rise.
What is the minimum down payment in Canada?
5% of the first $500,000, 10% of the portion between $500,000 and $1.5 million, and 20% for homes of $1.5 million or more.
How much is CMHC insurance?
The premium is 4.00% of the loan with 5% to 9.99% down, 3.10% with 10% to 14.99% down and 2.80% with 15% to 19.99% down. It is added to your mortgage. A 30-year insured amortization adds 0.20%.
Does the calculator include closing and selling costs?
Yes. Closing costs (such as land transfer tax and legal fees) are entered as a percentage of the price and treated as money the renter invests instead. Selling costs such as agent commissions are deducted from the home value at the end.
What investment return should I use?
Use a realistic long-term return for how you would invest, after fees. A conservative figure gives a more cautious comparison. Try several values to see how sensitive the result is.
Want to double-check? Use this rent vs buy calculator.